Cox & Walsh — Estate agents with a difference

Valuation reviews

A second opinion should add clarity.

A valuation can leave questions about its date, assumptions, comparisons or conclusion. Cox & Walsh can review an existing property report and provide an opinion suited to the issue you need to understand.

Identify the concern precisely

An unexpected figure is not, by itself, evidence that a valuation is wrong. The first step is to identify what the report was asked to do and whether that matches the decision now being made. A historical valuation and a current sales appraisal may reasonably produce different figures.

Tell us who commissioned the report, its intended purpose, the relevant date and the specific points you want considered. Provide the complete report, including its assumptions and appendices, through an agreed secure method. A single extracted figure can omit important context.

Examine the basis and the evidence

A review may consider the property interest, description, measurement basis, condition, inspection limits and treatment of rights or occupation. It may also examine whether the comparisons are genuinely relevant and how differences have been addressed.

The Residential Property Price Register is one useful source, but its information has limitations. It does not supply every physical detail needed for a comparison, and some transactions require particular care. A sound review examines the evidence in context rather than treating the nearest published price as decisive.

Agree the level of work

An initial consultation, a written review and a fresh valuation are different pieces of work. We agree which is appropriate, what information is available and whether an inspection or further investigation is needed.

The outcome may support the original conclusion, identify unanswered questions or reach a different reasoned opinion. If the matter involves proceedings, a complaint or a formal challenge, the recipient’s requirements and the advice of the relevant legal professional should be established at the outset.

Your questions, answered.

Can you review only the final value?

We need the context. The complete report, purpose, date, assumptions and the reason for your concern help establish whether a review is useful.

Does a review replace the original report?

Not automatically. Its status and intended use depend on the instruction. We can distinguish a review from a fresh valuation or a formal expert report.

Sources and further reading

Call the officeThinking of selling?